Feb 8, 2012

POTS - An Epidemic of Misdiagnosis

POTS patients and people with other forms of dysautonomia, such as Orthostatic Intolerance and Neurocardiogenic Syncope, are frequently misdiagnosed, sometimes for years before the accurate dysautonomia diagnosis is discovered.  Probably the most common thing they are misdiagnosed with is anxiety or panic disorder.  Some of the physical symptoms of POTS overlap with the physical symptoms of a panic attack, but they are definitely not the same thing.

Doctors are human.  Humans make mistakes.  Thus, doctors makes mistakes.  But mistakes and misdiagnosis within the medical field are much more common that most people realize.

In their book entitled, "Top Screwups Doctors Make and How To Avoid Them," authors Joe Graedon and Teresa Graedon, Ph.D. call misdiagnosis a silent epidemic and note that this issue has not even been studied until quite recently.

In 2009, doctors Peter Pronovost, MD, PhD and David Newman-Toker, MD, PhD wrote landmark commentary in the Journal of the American Medical Association: "Diagnostic Error - The Next Frontier for Patient Safety," which found that "[a]n estimated 40,000 to 80,000 U.S. hospital deaths results from misdiagnosis annually.  Roughly 5% of autopsies reveal lethal diagnostic errors for which a correct diagnosis coupled with treatment could have averted death."  Misdiagnosis "represent and enormous unmeasured source of preventable mortality, morbidity and costs."

While precise statistics on diagnostic errors remain unknown, because there is no uniform and mandatory reporting system, data from autopsies spanning several decades consistently reveal error rates of 10-15%, with some reports finding up to 20%.  And that only includes people whose misdiagnosis resulted in death.  The percentage of patients who are misdiagnosed, who survive and just live their lives thinking they have an illness they don't really have, and sometimes being given dangerous medications they don't need, is potentially much greater.  Add to that people who are really sick whose doctors misdiagnose them as having nothing wrong.

The Graedons also identify the #1 reason doctors misdiagnose their patients - overconfidence.  They note that "[h]umility, fallibility and uncertainty are not generally valued or modeled by medical mentors."  According to the international disease-classification system, there are over 13,600 recognized diagnoses (that number doesn't count new or yet to be discovered illnesses) and for each one there are a myriad of different remedies.  There are now 6,000 drugs and 4,000 medical and surgical procedures.  

Only a truly arrogant, and frankly ignorant, person could believe that he is capable of mastering all of this information - no less sorting it out within a 5 minute consult with a new patient.  Yet, many a doctor will scoff at his patient for asking questions, bringing a journal article for him to read or inquiring as to a particular diagnosis that the patient suspects he may have.  In fact, some studies have shown that the LEAST competent physicians are often the most confident in their abilities.  Why does that not surprise me?

In 2006, the New Your Times reported on this same problem, Why Doctors So Often Get It Wrong"With all the tools available to modern medicine — the blood tests and M.R.I.'s and endoscopes — you might think that misdiagnosis has become a rare thing. But you would be wrong. Studies of autopsies have shown that doctors seriously misdiagnose fatal illnesses about 20 percent of the time. So millions of patients are being treated for the wrong disease.  As shocking as that is, the more astonishing fact may be that the rate has not really changed since the 1930's. "No improvement!" was how an article in the normally exclamation-free Journal of the American Medical Association summarized the situation."

The New York Times went on to state, "[u]nder the current medical system, doctors, nurses, lab technicians and hospital executives are not actually paid to come up with the right diagnosis. They are paid to perform tests and to do surgery and to dispense drugs.  There is no bonus for curing someone and no penalty for failing, except when the mistakes rise to the level of malpractice. So even though doctors can have the best intentions, they have little economic incentive to spend time double-checking their instincts, and hospitals have little incentive to give them the tools to do so."

Now, don't get me wrong, I don't think overconfidence is the sole reason people get misdiagnosed.  Sometimes diseases are simply hard to figure out.  Some of the blame can lay at the feet of the insurance industry and government insurance programs, which have turned medicine into a mass-production line of patients being pushed in and out of their doctors offices at the speed of lightening.  Blame can also go to the medical schools who value rote memory of facts and figures, rather than complex problem solving and 'out of the box' thinking.  There are lots of factors that add up to the unacceptably high rate of misdiagnosis.

In terms of POTS, Orthostatic Hypotension and Neurocardiogenic Syncope, misdiagnosis is extremely common. A large percentage of POTS patients get misdiagnosed as having "just some anxiety" or "it's just stress," "panic disorder," "generalized anxiety disorder," or even worse "malingering" or "looking for attention."

As a patient who was given a misdiagnosis like this by a doctor who was neither a psychologist, nor a psychiatrist, I can tell you there is nothing more disheartenting and frustrating for a patient who is looking for answers and who wants to get better and get their old 'healthy' life back, than being told they are just anxious or looking for attention.  Yes, some arrogant prick of a doctor, who doesn't even know me, decided that the reason I was passing out and having chest pains and losing weight rapidly and having swollen lymph glands and sheet drenching night sweats and diarrhea 10 times a day was because I was looking for attention from my husband because I was 31 and didn't have kids yet.  I was so shocked when he said this, I thought he was kidding around.  He wasn't.  Not that is was any of his damn businesses, but the reason I don't have children is that I am a busy career woman, who put herself through law school and her husband through grad school and saved up enough money to by a six bedroom house in a well-to-do zip code before I was 30, all while serving on the Board of Directors of several different charities and being active in local politics.  Yeah, I've been busy, and I thought it would be better to wait until my husband and I were ready financially and career-wise before we started popping out kids.  After my encounter with this bozo, I jokingly gave myself a new diagnosis, "want-to-slap-that-doctoritis."

Thankfully, I trusted my gut instincts enough to ignore him and to keep looking for answers as to what was going on with my body.  Sure enough, several months later, an intellectually curious neurologist decided to take me on as a patient and he figured out that I had severe autonomic neuropathy and POTS.  Last time I checked, you can't imagine your way to getting widespread nerve damage.  And then a year after the nerve damage was found, another neurologist figured out the cause of that nerve damage - an autoimmune disease was attacking my nerves - Sjogren's Syndrome - and it had already done some very serious damage.  So much for the "you're just looking for attention" diagnosis I got from that earlier doctor.  I'm not one to hold a grudge, because that is unhealthy. Having a grudge is not a problem, holding it in and letting if fester is the problem.  So the next time I ran into doctor bozo, I let him have it. 

To paraphrase the conversation.... "Hi, nice to see you too.  Hey guess what, you were TOTALLY WRONG!  I'm not making it up.  Turns out I have a life threatening autoimmune disease attacking my nerves and organs.  Oh, and nice to miss the low aldosterone I had!  That should have been a big clue.  Aren't you supposed to be an endocrinologist?  Maybe you should stop trying to be a shrink and focus a little more on your own speciality." Two of his nurses give me a high five after he left the room mumbling and one of them tells me he treated her elderly mother the same way.  He said she was just going through the change of life, and it turns out she had thyroid cancer!

And my story is pretty much the same as almost every other POTS patient I have met.  Why does this happen to us?

Could it be because the majority of POTS patients are women and there is still some lingering gender-based discrimination in the medical profession?

Could it be because the majority of POTS patients are young women - and there is a general resistance within the medical community to think that young people could be so sick?

Could it because the majority of POTS patients look very normal, and some doctors are naive enough to think that you have to look sick to be sick?

Could it be because POTS symptoms often don't show up on basic blood and urine tests, and too many doctors are unwilling to look beyond the basics?

Could it be because many doctors, especially those who graduated medical school before the mid-1990s, have never heard of POTS?

Could it be because doctors, even those who have heard of POTS, have no idea how to diagnose POTS?

Could it be because doctors are so rushed by our medical system, that they result to practicing hamster on a treadmill medicine and they don't have enough time to really listen to a patient with complex illnesses that come with a long list of complaints?

The answer to all of the above questions is a resounding YES.  

So what can we do to improve this situation?  Stay tuned for my next post on a new POTS education and awareness campaign targeting the medical community.


  1. Yes ma'am, you said it all. The doctards abound.

  2. Thanks for writing this - it says SO much so well. Misdiagnosis has cost me my job, my home, my fiance and now my health and entire life. I am STILL fighting against the system to get even the basic help needed here in the UK.
    I have had other complaints and for sure the majority of the doctors "in the system" do not care about patient outcomes, humility, doing their job as best they can - it seems they are just fulfilling their time obligations and "seeing" the required number of patients but to be honest for all its worth they might as well go into the waiting room and LOOK at the patients and then just pick some prejudiced diagnosis out of thin air and dismiss them all.
    I dont mean to distrust everyone in the medical community - ive met some brilliant doctors (unfortunately its normally just ive met them randomly rather than been treated by them). Surely there needs to be some more "performance analysis" based on the outcomes not on how many people they can send back out their door in a day (with no more clue or help than when they went in). There would be an incentive to work, to keep learning and up to date with their field of medicine. Even in my sports coaching job there were annual seminars that were compulsory, training had to be updated and you were awarded for pupils achieving results in competitions or passing tests.
    Its tough as often we dont know if the diagnosis is right until sometime later - like in your case- but there is no accountability for them if they do get it massively wrong and cause irreparable damage.

  3. EXCELLENT Post! Anxiously awaiting the next one